Supreme Court Ruling on Right to Lie Exposes GOP Group for Doing So

United States Supreme Court - Washington D.C.
United States Supreme Court - Washington D.C.
United States Supreme Court – Washington D.C.

The First Amendment is pretty clear.  Government cannot abridge or restrict your freedom of speech or expression.  A newspaper, website, or a cable network can, because they control the content.  But the government cannot step in and censor you — even if what you’re saying is a baldfaced lie.  That’s the gist of a recent ruling surrounding the conservative group The Susan B. Anthony List, a right wing version of Emily’s List which seeks to get progressive pro-choice Democratic women elected.  The Susan B. Anthony List is supported to get Republican women elected but instead, they wind up backing traditional rich white Republican menfor office.

This case decided by the Supreme Court filed by the Susan B. Anthony List upholds the right of organizations to overtly lie.  And in filing the case, the Susan B. Anthony Group had to admit it lied in a series of billboards about Obamacare and Ohio congressman Steven Driehaus’s alleged support for “taxpayer-funded abortion” under the law — patently false under Federal Law.  The group was going to be denied the right to post the speech on billboards under Ohio’s False Statement law.  The Supreme Court didn’t rule on the constitutionality of the law, but rather on the standing of the Susan B. Anthony Group to sue.

From TalkingPointsMemo:

Conservatives including Justice Antonin Scalia have sardonically dubbed it the “Ministry of Truth” statute.

“The question in this case is whether their preenforcement challenge to that law is justiciable—and in particular, whether they have alleged a sufficiently imminent injury for the purposes of Article III. We conclude that they have,” Thomas wrote for the Court.

In 2010, SBA List sought to put up a billboard accusing then-Rep. Steve Driehaus, a Democrat, of supporting taxpayer-funded abortion by voting for Obamacare. Driehaus complained to state officials, saying it ran afoul of the campaign lies law. Although the state didn’t take action, the billboard company refused to put up the ad, which caused SBA List to sue, alleging the law had a chilling effect on its free speech rights.

Here’s the summary from The Daily Beast:

The law makes it a criminal offense to knowingly or recklessly make false statements about a candidate—what ordinary people might call lying. The maximum penalty for making such lies in the context of an Ohio electoral campaign is a fine of $5,000 and six months in prison.

Ask any 5-year-old and, if they’re being honest, they’ll tell you lying is wrong. That doesn’t mean it should be illegal. And it certainly doesn’t mean that criminalizing false speech is constitutional. For this reason, the ACLU and other staunch defenders of the First Amendment filed amici briefs arguing that the Supreme Court should indeed allow the Susan B. Anthony List’s lawsuit to proceed.

To be clear, the Court did not rule as to whether the Ohio False Statement Law is constitutional—it simply ruled that the Susan B. Anthony List has legal justification in suing. And without a doubt, part of the reason that the Susan B. Anthony List has standing is because they lie.

In 2010, the Susan B. Anthony List wanted to run billboards arguing that Democratic Rep. Steven Driehaus had supported “taxpayer-funded abortion” because he voted for Obamacare. This is a flat-out lie. Nothing in the Affordable Care Act could remotely be possibly even a little bit construed as providing taxpayer funding for abortion—because the law, very simply, doesn’t do that. This claim, recklessly tossed about by those on the right, has been roundly dismissed by PolitiFact as false. In fact, there’s already a federal law—on the books since 1976—that prevents federal funds from being used to pay for abortions. Of course this hasn’t stopped anti-abortion activists from insisting otherwise, nor their Republican allies in Congress from introducing legislation that literally does the same thing as the laws already on the books.

It’s certainly not hard to imagine the Ohio law having a chilling effect on free speech and by extension, our democracy—especially in increasingly fast-and-furious electoral campaigns that by nature involve public figures who usually aren’t subject to standard, stringent libel laws. Plus smears and baseless accusations are the fuel of modern politics. That said, perhaps it shouldn’t be illegal to outright lie in a political campaign… but that doesn’t make it right. To even file this lawsuit in the first place, the Susan B. Anthony List had to admit it lied. The lying wasn’t an accident or even a momentary lapse in good judgment. It was conscious and deliberate. The ultimate constitutionality of the Ohio False Statement Law is still up in the air but what’s clear is that a right-wing organization put lying at the center of its campaign strategy—disappointing facts but increasingly unanimously common across the right.

Now if your progressive email box is like mine, your conservative friends are constantly sending you right wing propaganda to prove Obama is evil, his wife hates America and bill Clinton is responsible for 9/11 for not taking Bin Laden into custody when he was President.  They also believe Hillary has brain damage from a fall, Bush was never wrong about anything, and Sarah Palin is our only hope.

The ability to deliberately lie and have it passed off as truth now has the support of the Supreme Court.  And the decision was unanimous.  I’m sure Lee Atwater is doing a happy dance somewhere in Hell for this ruling.


  1. “Obamacare states that at least one of the plans in each exchange must exclude elective abortion coverage by 2017. The decision to include coverage is ultimately left to the insurer.[3] But federally subsidized tax credits will remain available even for the plans that do cover elective abortion, potentially sending taxpayer funds to pay for health coverage that includes elective abortion.”
    Key words: ‘must exclude’

  2. I support my right to lie and the right to pay others to lie for me. For what may seem a lie to to some, may be the the absolute truth to me.

  3. Currently, 25 states ban insurance companies from covering abortion. The other states require an abortion insurance rider, which doesn’t exist. So, federal funding of abortion, even indirectly, doesn’t exist. It’s a specious argument.

  4. The Henry Hyde Amendment, passed in 1976, bans federally funded abortions. At least if you’re going to trash ‘Obamacare,’ get your facts straight.

  5. I support the right of everyone to lie – except to the authorities – but maybe even then for just cause.

    Consider the case of Lois Lerner ……..

  6. “The First Amendment is pretty clear. Government cannot abridge or restrict your freedom of speech or expression.”

    Not to be nit picky. The 1st Amendment says no such thing. It states:

    “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”

    “Congress” is the operative word here. It says nothing about the Executive or Judicial Branches of government. Both of whom have exercised their authority on numerous occasions to limit free speech. The Legislative branch has indeed passed laws limiting speech. But that might be a topic for another day.

Comments are closed.